project_zeta_q026_2_locked_psi_eta_beta_star_re_answer_2026_05_17

Q-026.2 ψ.η.β★ PARTIAL AMEND LOCKED 2026-05-17 — super-amendment under v3.15

Lock: ψ.η.β★ PARTIAL AMEND. A-173 super-amendment supersedes A-166 (Q-026 ψ.η original) + A-167 (Q-026.1 jurisdiction-uplift). Arch-state v3.67 → v3.68. SECOND FULL v3.15 production use after Q-024.1 Φ.η.ε★.

Trigger

Rich-directive 2026-05-17 BST sequence per session resume prompt — Q-021..Q-027 re-answer under v3.15 substrate-consultation methodology per A-169 PROCEDURAL marker. Q-026 ψ.η + Q-026.1 jurisdiction-uplift selected as Phase-3 first-Q re-answer ahead of Q-021/Q-022/Q-023 (Phase-3 sequence priority).

ψ.η.β★ shape — 3 NEW elements over A-166+A-167

1. FaithTraditionPillar enum REFRESH per Q-024.1 Φ.η.ε★ A-171 — 10 sub-pillar values across:
   • Muslim sub-schemes: muslim-hanafi / muslim-shafii / muslim-maliki / muslim-hanbali Sunni 4 schools + muslim-jafari Jafari Shia
   • Hindu sub-schemes: hindu-mitakshara / hindu-dayabhaga
   • Jewish sub-schemes: jewish-halachic-strict / jewish-israeli-civil-with-halachic-recognition
   • Singapore-Muslim: singapore-muslim (MUIS-anchored FIRST per T49 wave-1)
   • Day-1 advisory NULLABLE; transactional Phase-1.5+ wave-1 per Q-024.1 5-criteria composite trigger
2. NEW WillFormScheme SKOS Day-1 with 5 universal classifier values + German verbatim labels per T56 Reid/de Waal/Zimmermann Comparative Succession Law vols 2+3:
   • WF1 attested-writing — UK&W Wills Act 1837 s.9 + Scotland attested per RoW Act 1995 + post-COVID remote attestation Phase-1.5+ Law Commission 2025 final report
   • WF2 holographic — Switzerland Eigenhändiges Testament ZGB Art 505 + Scotland holograph per RoW Act 1995 (NOT VALID UK&W)
   • WF3 notarial-public — Switzerland öffentliches Testament ZGB Art 499-501 + Scotland notarial per RoW Act 1995
   • WF4 nuncupative-oral — Switzerland Nottestament ZGB Art 506-508 + UK&W privileged Wills Act 1837 s.11 (military/seamen <1%)
   • WF5 statutory-form — UK&W MCA 2005 s.18 + Switzerland Erbvertrag ZGB Art 494-497 + Scotland inventoried statutory per Confirmation of Executors Scotland Act 1858
3. NEW will_form slot on Will class with range: WillFormScheme + required: true + ext_inherit_tier: REQUIRED + catala_check: WillFormJurisdictionCheck (rule body Phase-5-deferred typing surface Phase-1)

v6.6 substrate consulted (clean-break distilled — no v6.6 paths in lock outputs)

3 Phase-1 jurisdictions + 3 faith pillars distilled to v2-native vocabulary per v3.15 step 6h. Source-law citations only (Wills Act 1837 + ZGB Art 460-540 + Requirements of Writing Scotland Act 1995 + MCA 2005 + Succession Scotland Act 1964 + Trusts and Succession Scotland Act 2024 + Quran 4:11-12 + Hindu Succession Act 1956 + Talmudic Bava Batra + Israeli Succession Law 5765-1965 + s.10 Arbitration Act 1996 Beth Din UK carve-out).

Tier-2 pgvector substrate-correcting findings (8)

Re-run on 8 queries × 8 results = 64 chunks. RC1 5/5 (was 3/5 first-pass).

#	Finding	Source
1	German verbatim Swiss labels (öffentliches Testament + Eigenhändiges Testament + Nottestament)	T56-document-signing-eidas.md #30 + Reid/de Waal/Zimmermann vols 2+3
2	UK&W writing+signature UNSETTLED status post-Law-Commission-2025 final report	T56 §8.22-8.31 + 8.32-8.33
3	Scotland probative subscript + presumption of due execution + post-COVID remote attestation	T56 Spice 2025 SB-25-06 pp 19-20
4	EMPIRICAL-ONLY-RESIDUAL ★ verdict treating 6 jurisdictions equally validates international-symmetric framing	T52-uk-gov-agency-tech.md #62
5	LinkML EnumDefinition ↔ skos:ConceptScheme mapping with meaning: IRI binding	T13-LINKML-notes.md #62 + #10
6	NMDC pattern (MIxS + ENVO) directly transferable to one-core-schema + per-jurisdiction-extension	T37-DEEP-LINKML-notes.md #32
7	LinkML PR #3187 children_are_mutually_disjoint Phase-1.5+ uplift candidate	T44-DEEP6-LINKML-IMPLEMENTATION-notes.md #23
8	No AKN profile exists for Islamic fiqh / halakhic / Hindu dharma — validates P-04 OASIS persona (c)-class fold	T7-AKOMA-NTOSO-ELI-ECLI-notes.md #27

Methodology footprint (SECOND FULL v3.15)

Step	Outcome
Step 6 RESEARCH SWEEP RC1-RC7 self-score	4.71 avg (RC1+RC3+RC4+RC5+RC6+RC7 5/5; RC2 3/5 — no new web tracks, accepted per substrate-recency)
Step 6h v6.6 SUBSTRATE CONSULTATION	Applied 3 jurisdictions + 3 faith pillars distilled clean-break; NO v6.6 paths in outputs
Step 6b Tier-2 pgvector	Re-run 8 queries × 8 results — 8 substrate-correcting findings integrated
Step 7 scorecard	14 criteria × 6 options; Wsum 5.00 Σ raw 70/70
Step 7 per-flavour audit	FV 5.0 + IC 5.0 + FR 5.0 cleared no near-veto; ψ.η.α FR near-vetoed at c6+c14 = 2/5 + cascade-violations Q-015 + Q-024.1
Step 7 international-scope sub-audit	PASS — 3 Phase-1 jurisdictions symmetric Day-1 + T52 EMPIRICAL-ONLY-RESIDUAL ★ external validation
Step 7 cascade-compliance sub-audit	5/5 — honours A-115 + Q-015 λ.η + Q-005 κ.δ + Q-008 R.δ + Q-012 π.ζ + Q-014 V5+ + Q-019 ε.ζ + Q-021 χ.η + Q-024.1 Φ.η.ε★ + Q-026.1 + Q-027 ξ.η’★
Sensitivity perturbations	7/8 robust + 1/8 borderline-but-leading (c6 ÷2 over-reliance check +0.06 still leads)
Step 7.5 named-persona pass	5 personas (P-01 Catala + P-04 OASIS + P-05 W3C VC + P-07 Mishcon + P-08 Lawsky) 14 objections (5 (a) + 6 (b) + 3 (c)-folded-inline-via-cascade-routing)
Step 8 decision-quality check	Counter-argument (ψ.η.δ devil-min) + pre-mortem (LinkML/Scotland/Swiss-notary/cascade-violation 4 modes) + cross-architecture verification (12 locked artefacts) + stakeholder sanity check (5 stakeholders)
Step 9 consecutive-bold-synthesis counter-pattern check	SIXTH consecutive bold-synthesis lock post-Q-025 META-break; counter-pattern check CONFIRMS substrate-derived not aspiration-derived

11 sub_clarifications_locked

1. preserve_8_prior_phase_2_lock_integration_day_1 — Q-005 + Q-008 + Q-012 + Q-014 + Q-015 + Q-019 + Q-021 + Q-024.1 + A-98 + Q-027 cross-link preserved
2. q_026_1_jurisdiction_uplift_folded_into_a_173_supersession — single super-amendment subsumes A-166 + A-167
3. faith_tradition_pillar_enum_refresh_per_q_024_1_a_171_sub_schemes_10_values — Sunni 4 + Jafari + Mitakshara/Dayabhaga + halachic-strict/israeli-civil + Singapore-MUIS
4. will_form_scheme_skos_day_1_with_5_universal_classifier_values — WF1-WF5 universal + jurisdiction-symmetric SSSOM mapping
5. will_form_scheme_source_law_verbatim_german_labels_per_t56_reid_de_waal_zimmermann — öffentliches Testament + Eigenhändiges Testament + Nottestament per T56 vols 2+3
6. international_symmetric_validated_per_t52_empirical_only_residual_verdict — T52 external validation 6-axis symmetric
7. catala_will_form_jurisdiction_check_rule_body_phase_5_deferred_typing_surface_phase_1 — Phase-FIT-FORBIDDEN concrete-artefact authoring deferred Phase-5; typing surface lockable Phase-1
8. akoma_ntoso_will_family_mapping_phase_1_5_sssom_row_per_a_141_standards_engagement — P-04 OASIS (c)-fold via cascade-routing (T7 confirms no AKN profile for faith-tradition sources)
9. conflict_of_laws_recognition_phase_3_q_030_probate_recognition_scope — P-07 Mishcon (c)-fold (Wills Act 1963 s.1 + Brussels IV-bis + Hague Convention 1961 → Q-030)
10. case_law_integration_phase_3_q_030_probate — P-08 Lawsky (c)-fold (Banks v Goodfellow capacity + Wills Act 1837 s.9 interpretation → Q-030)
11. linkml_pr_3187_children_are_mutually_disjoint_phase_1_5_uplift_trigger — when LinkML 1.11+ ships final, uplift WillFormScheme + JurisdictionScheme + FaithTraditionPillar to mutual-disjointness enforceability

S1 lock-BLOCKING spike outcome — VALIDATED

7/7 generators emit clean on amended schema:

Generator	Lines	Notes
gen-pydantic	458	preserved
gen-json-schema	277	preserved
gen-typescript	195	+51L over v1.0 (WillFormScheme + FaithTraditionPillar refresh)
gen-jsonld	1366	+131L over v1.0
gen-python	567	+105L over v1.0
gen-shacl —non-closed	173	6 NodeShapes preserved (Will + TestatorRole + WitnessRole + ExecutorRole + Bequest + SubstitutionClause)
gen-sqla	183	preserved
Total	3219L	+430L over v1.0

False-positive “error/exception” matches due to revoked-by-marriage description text (“conditional-marriage exception s.18(3)-(4)”). No actual generator failures.

Pattern observations

• FIRST super-amendment in cascade history — 2 prior A-numbers (A-166 + A-167) FOLDED into 1 new A-N (A-173). Previously only single-A-to-single-A supersessions (Q-024 → Q-024.1 + Q-025 → Q-025.1)
• SECOND FULL v3.15 production use validates v3.15 methodology footprint — step 6h v6.6 consultation + step 6b Tier-2 pgvector + step 7 international-scope + cascade-compliance sub-audits + step 7.5 named-persona pass with 5 personas
• CLEAN-BREAK DISCIPLINE HOLDS — Q-026.2 lock outputs contain NO v6.6 paths despite v6.6 substrate consultation; source-law citations only
• SIXTH consecutive bold-synthesis lock post-Q-025 META-break (Q-026 + Q-026.1 + Q-027 + Q-024.1 + Q-025.1-light-cycle + Q-026.2); counter-pattern check CONFIRMS substrate-derived (Wills Act 1837 + ZGB + RoW Act 1995 all exist Day-1 statute-grounded; not aspiration-pattern-matching)
• TWENTY-SECOND refined-prompt-era ζ.2 lock (counting Q-026.2)
• A-173 supersession chain — A-166 Q-026 ψ.η + A-167 Q-026.1 → A-173 Q-026.2 ψ.η.β★ (PROVISIONAL flag from A-169 removed for both Q-026 + Q-026.1 rows; both rows now AUTHORITATIVE-via-A-173)
• Tier-2 pgvector demonstrated value — 8 substrate-correcting findings closed RC1 gap from 3/5 to 5/5 AND surfaced 2 new sub_clarifications (will_form_scheme_source_law_verbatim_german_labels + international_symmetric_validated_per_t52_empirical_only_residual_verdict) + 1 Phase-1.5+ uplift trigger (linkml_pr_3187_phase_1_5_uplift_trigger)

Remaining PROVISIONAL per A-169

• A-161 (Q-021 χ.η) — 80% v3.15-score, LOW re-answer priority
• A-162 (Q-022 σ̃.η) — 88%, VERY LOW priority
• A-163 (Q-023 ω̃.ι) — 85%, LOW priority
• A-168 (Q-027 ξ.η’★) — Phase 3 sequence NEXT

Q-028 SubstitutionClause deferred until re-answer cycle complete.

External academic review still warranted

Per A-141 — internal-simulation named-persona pass (P-01 Catala + P-04 OASIS + P-05 W3C VC + P-07 Mishcon + P-08 Lawsky) widened objection-set materially but does NOT substitute for genuine external review. Standards-engagement §A-141 should target Phase-1.5+ academic peer review post-Q-026.2 lock alongside Q-024.1 faith-tradition.

Related

• [[refined_prompt_v3_15_released_v6_6_substrate_consultation_clean_break_2026_05_17]] — v3.15 directive
• [[project_zeta_q024_1_q025_1_faith_tradition_cluster_re_answer_2026_05_17]] — Q-024.1 Φ.η.ε★ FIRST FULL v3.15 production use pattern (Q-026.2 second)
• [[project_zeta_q26_locked_psi_eta_wills_will_class_shape_mvp_2026_05_05]] — Q-026 ψ.η original lock (A-166 superseded)
• [[project_zeta_q27_locked_xi_eta_prime_wills_bequest_class_shape_mvp_2026_05_17]] — Q-027 ξ.η’★ (next re-answer target)
• [[project_zeta_q20_locked_omega_zeta_star_redux_2026_05_17]] — Q-020 META-Q redux pattern
• A-166 Q-026 ψ.η original → A-173 supersession
• A-167 Q-026.1 jurisdiction-uplift → A-173 supersession
• A-171 Q-024.1 Φ.η.ε★ — pillar sub-scheme substrate consumed Day-1
• A-172 Q-025.1 ω̄.γ.β★ — Phase 2 closure-check substrate consumed Day-1
• T56-document-signing-eidas.md — German verbatim Swiss labels + Reid/de Waal/Zimmermann canonical cite
• T52-uk-gov-agency-tech.md — EMPIRICAL-ONLY-RESIDUAL ★ external validation 6-axis symmetric
• spike-reference at docs/superpowers/specs/spike-references/2026-05-17-q026-2-partial-amend/wills.linkml.yaml v1.1