Q-036 ι.η★ Probate.AdministrationAccount MVP LOCKED 2026-05-18T17:00 BST
Top-line
- Locked pick: ι.η★ universal-classifier composition Day-1 + Q-033 SM cross-link + Q-035 assents_recorded + Q-CM-1 transfers_recorded + 2 NEW SKOS schemes + Re Tankard 1942 Uthwatt doctrine due-diligence boolean + module-close-at-7/8 sub_clarification per Option F
- Amendment: A-186; arch-state v3.80 → v3.81
- Wsum: 4.94 / 5.00 (margin +1.37 ROBUST over true runner-up ι.γ)
- Cascade-compliance: 17/17 ROBUST
- Personas: 3/3 PASS — P-07 Mishcon + P-09 HMRC + P-10 Berenbrok (lighter pass per L1 module-close-appropriate)
- S1: 7/7 PASS (pydantic 363L + json-schema 146L + typescript 94L + jsonld 1245L + python 358L + sqla 83L + shacl —non-closed 99L 1 NodeShape)
- S2: sssom-py validate exit 0 (14 rows)
- RC1-RC7: 34/35 (97% ROBUST)
- Substrate-correcting findings: ZERO — pure synthesis from L2 inheritance; NOT a defect, confirms L2 working as designed
Lock numbering + significance
- THIRTY-FIFTH refined-prompt-era ζ.2 lock under v3.17 L1-L5
- SECOND SUBSTANTIVE Q under v3.17 (Q-035 was first)
- SECOND L2 substrate-sweep inheritance application — inherits_substrate_from Q-033 + Q-035 + Q-032 + Q-029 + Q-CM-1
- FIFTH FULL CASCADE-Q FILE under v3.16 (precedents Q-032 + Q-033 + Q-CM-1 + Q-035)
- SIXTEENTH consecutive bold-synthesis — EW-4 FIRES at module-close
- PROBATE-MODULE SUBSTANTIVE CLOSE AT 7/8 — Probate-module Phase-α complete
Class shape (14 slots)
- id
- estate REQUIRED FK Q-029 β.η A-177
- probate_administration REQUIRED FK Q-033 ζ.η A-181
- personal_representative REQUIRED FK Q-032 ε.η A-180
- account_type REQUIRED AccountTypeScheme (NEW; 4 values)
- account_status REQUIRED AccountStatusScheme (NEW; 3 values)
- period_start REQUIRED date Mopsa-c
- period_end REQUIRED date Mopsa-c
- account_prepared_date REQUIRED date Mopsa-c
- assents_recorded multivalued NULLABLE FK to Q-035 θ.η A-185 AssentToBeneficiary records
- transfers_recorded multivalued NULLABLE FK to Q-CM-1 η.η A-183 AssetTransferEvent records
- due_diligence_compliance_check_passed REQUIRED boolean (Re Tankard 1942 Uthwatt)
- faith_tradition_pillar NULLABLE per A-115
- notes
2 NEW SKOS schemes
- AccountTypeScheme (4) — interim-account (AEA 1925 s.25 PR account duty) + final-account (administration-closed trigger) + residuary-account (AEA 1925 s.46 residuary distribution) + estate-distribution-account (partner-firm-DD readability format)
- AccountStatusScheme (3) — draft + submitted + approved (monotonic; AccountStatusTransitionCheck Catala rule enforces)
Re Tankard 1942 Uthwatt due-diligence doctrine
Canonical UK&W authority cited Day-1 via due_diligence_compliance_check_passed REQUIRED boolean:
- “It is the duty of executors, as a matter of the due administration of the estate, to pay the debts of their testator with due diligence having regard to the assets in their hands which are properly applicable for that purpose” (Uthwatt J at 72)
- NOT a strict 1-year deadline (P&K §21-13 quoting Uthwatt at 72-73)
- PR liable to creditors AND beneficiaries for failure (P&K §21-12)
- Will can modify duty as against beneficiaries (NOT against creditors) (Uthwatt at 74)
- Catala DueDiligenceCheck Phase-5 rule body load-bearing for partner-firm-DD + P-09 HMRC unpaid-IHT-liability check
4 Catala rules Phase-5-deferred (per MQ-008 tracking discipline)
- AccountTypeValidityCheck (P-01 fold; interim-before-final invariant)
- AccountStatusTransitionCheck (P-01 fold; draft → submitted → approved monotonic)
- DueDiligenceCheck (P-07 + P-09 fold; Re Tankard 1942 Uthwatt 3-prong test)
- SwissErbteilungAccountCheck Phase-1.5+ wave (P-10 Berenbrok fold; ZGB Art 596-607 + Art 610 III)
All 4 declared in phase_5_catala_rule_bodies: frontmatter per MQ-008.
v3.17 L5 anti-pattern early-warning (BOTH FIRE)
- EW-1 (3-consecutive-zero-c-objections) — 4th-consecutive zero-c → retrospective NOW
- EW-4 (≥5-consecutive bold-synthesis) — 16th-consecutive → phase-boundary retrospective FIRES at module-close (this Q IS module-close per Option F)
- EW-2/EW-3/EW-5 not fired
Retrospective doc ~1 page authored alongside Q-036 commit per Rich-decision-4.
Phase-1.5+ richard-tasks
ZERO new tasks added for Q-036 — substrate covered by inheritance; no new uplift candidates beyond Q-035’s 31-33.
Probate-module substantive close at 7/8
Per Rich-decisions 1+3+4 from Probate-module-boundary look-ahead 2026-05-18T16:45 BST:
- Probate-module substantively closes at 7/8 NOT 8/8
- A-124 budgeted 8/8 over-budgeted
- Remaining 2 candidates deferred to Phase-1.5+ trigger-gated:
- DeedOfVariation (partially covered by Q-CM-1 transfer_mechanism=deed-of-variation)
- ContestedProbate / IFPA1975DependantsApplication / IhtFiling (trigger-gated)
- Q-budget reduction recovered: Trusts +1 + Assets +1
NEXT
- EW-4+EW-1 retrospective doc (~1 page) — fires immediately post-Q-036 lock per Rich-decision-4 (committed alongside Q-036 cascade)
- Q-T1 Trusts.Trust container — next substantive Q post-retrospective per Rich-decision-3; L2 inheritance from Q-032 + Q-008 R.δ + Q-CM-1 + Q-024.1 anticipated; ~2-3h cycle
- Phase-3 axis 10/30-45 → 11/30-45
- Probate module 6/8 → 7/8 SUBSTANTIVE CLOSE
- Trusts module 0/3-5 → starting
Files committed
docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-29-multi-phase-audit/answered-questions/Q-036-zeta-iota-eta-probate-administration-account-mvp-locked.md(NEW; cascade-Q FIRST per v3.16)docs/superpowers/specs/inherit-v2-architecture-state.md(v3.80 → v3.81 + A-186 prose)docs/superpowers/specs/spike-references/2026-05-18-q036-administration-account-mvp/probate.linkml.yaml(NEW)docs/superpowers/specs/spike-references/2026-05-18-q036-administration-account-mvp/probate-administration-account-mapping-set.sssom.tsv(NEW)docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-29-multi-phase-audit/phase-3-probate-module-close-ew4-ew1-retrospective.md(NEW; ~1-page retrospective per Rich-decision-4)~/.claude/projects/-home-richardd-testatetech/memory/project_zeta_q036_locked_*.md(this file)~/.claude/projects/-home-richardd-testatetech/memory/project_active_work.md(entry)~/.claude/projects/-home-richardd-testatetech/memory/MEMORY.md(top entry)
Cross-link project_zeta_q035_locked_theta_eta_star_probate_assent_to_beneficiary_mvp_2026_05_18 (predecessor; FIRST substantive Q under v3.17) + project_zeta_q_cm_1_locked_eta_eta_star_transfer_asset_transfer_event_canonical_primitive_mvp_2026_05_18 (Q-CM-1 transfers_recorded composition) + project_zeta_q033_locked_zeta_eta_star_probate_administration_state_machine_mvp_2026_05_18 (Q-033 SM cross-link) + feedback_recommendation_reply_template_format (β format validated again on Q-036 close-question).