TT Claude Memory

project_zeta_q13_registrations_phase_1_scope_2026_05_01

Properties1
descriptionζ-Q13 GAP-3 from ζ-Q9 closed; A-140 registers Wills + Probate registrations[] schema + A-55 verification-tier reuse Phase-1 ONLY; NO API integration; THIRD CONSECUTIVE CORE-over-Hybrid Rich-pattern

4 min read

⚠️ PRE-REFINED-PROMPT-archived 2026-05-01T20:45 BST per Full Phase-2-3 Reversion — this memory file records a lock that has been DISCARDED. The Q is queued for re-ask under refined-prompt v3.0 discipline. Original lock content preserved below for forensic continuity. Do not act on this memory’s recommendations as if locked. Audit-record: ~/testatetech/docs-strategy/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-29-multi-phase-audit/audit-records/2026-05-01-full-phase-2-3-re-ask-under-refined-prompt.md v1.0. Refined-prompt v3.0 reference: ~/testatetech/docs-strategy/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-29-multi-phase-audit/refined-end-of-turn-directive.md.

ζ-Q13 LOCKED Δ.β Schema + 3-tier verification Phase-1 ONLY 2026-05-01

Locked: 2026-05-01T05:55 BST. Amendment: A-140 in arch-state v3.25.

What Δ.β specifies

  • A-140 NEW: Wills.Will + Probate.ExecutedEstate canonical primitives gain optional registrations[] slot per LinkML schema
  • Registration sub-schema: registry (enum: NWR / RoS / Other) + referenceNumber (string) + registeredAt (datetime) + verificationTier (per A-55 MaturityScheme reuse) + optionalRegistryURL (string, optional)
  • A-55 MaturityScheme reuse — 3 verification tiers REUSE existing scheme: Unverified=Draft / Testator-uploaded=Candidate / Professionally referenced=Stable. NO new SKOS scheme RegistrationVerificationScheme.
  • NO API integration Phase-1 — NWR Trade API client (OneAdvanced ~£5/registration) + RoS manual workflow generator (Books of Council and Session, no API) deferred Phase-1.5+
  • NO new A-21 CI gates — G-NWR-INTEGRITY + G-ROS-WORKFLOW deferred Phase-1.5+
  • Symmetric-jurisdictional discipline preserved — Phase-1 doesn’t favour E&W (NWR) over Scotland (RoS); both deferred Phase-1.5+ uniformly per feedback_first_vertical_slice_symmetric_2026_04_24
  • Phase-3 effort: ~30 min LinkML schema extension; folds into Wills + Probate module-authoring sprints per A-124

What Δ.β does NOT include

  • NO API integration (NWR Trade API + RoS manual workflow → Phase-1.5+ sprints ~5-10 days each)
  • NO auto-registration on Will completion (deferred Phase-1.5+)
  • NO executor search post-death (deferred Phase-1.5+)
  • NO new SKOS classifier scheme (count stays at 23)
  • NO new cross-module primitive (count stays at 27)
  • NO new A-21 CI gates (count stays at 21)

Why Δ.β CORE chosen over Δ.ζ Hybrid

Δ.β 4.18 vs Δ.ζ 4.05 (margin 0.13 below 0.20 threshold; near-identical CORE-vs-Hybrid). 6/8 sensitivity perturbations preserve Δ.β. Δ.ζ Hybrid wins ONLY under #3 (Standards-track + AI-vendor + Acquirer amplified). Rich-pattern: third consecutive CORE-over-Hybrid pick (ζ-Q11 π.β + ζ-Q12 Θ.β + ζ-Q13 Δ.β). Codified as feedback_phase_3_q_minimum_change_preference discipline candidate (3 data points sufficient).

Why Δ.γ NWR-Phase-1 excluded on principle

Δ.γ wt-sum 3.32 > Δ.δ 2.95 numerically, but VIOLATES feedback_first_vertical_slice_symmetric_2026_04_24 discipline (asymmetric jurisdictional Phase-1 anti-E&W-creep). Disciplines override numerical scoring when violated. Pattern lock for future Phase-1 scope decisions.

Convergence

14 of 15 ζ.2-related decisions convergent under ζ.2 methodology pivot (only MQ-001 R2 reversal counted as divergent at the time, but R2 itself is convergent now).

Methodological observations

  1. Third consecutive CORE-over-Hybrid Rich-pattern — codify as feedback_phase_3_q_minimum_change_preference discipline. Discipline applies forward to all Phase-3 Q’s where top option is below 0.20 margin to a Hybrid alternative.
  2. A-55 MaturityScheme reuse pattern emerging — third reuse this session (registrations verification tier; A-104 WitnessEventBundle progressive-hardening; A-115 AdvisoryConsultation maturity gating). When 3-tier or N-tier categorisation appears, reach for existing SKOS scheme rather than authoring new.
  3. Symmetric-jurisdictional discipline kicked Δ.γ out on principle even though numerical scoring favoured it over Δ.δ. Disciplines override numerical scoring.
  4. Phase-3 audit converging extremely fast — Phase-3 Q-5 closes within ~13 minutes of Phase-3 Q-4. Phase-3 Q-count revised toward ~20 (was 20-30 → 20-26 → ~20).

Library gap

NO T-file specifically on NWR (OneAdvanced) Trade API or RoS (Books of Council and Session) interfaces. Per Rich’s “spikes must not be delayed” directive, this folds into Phase-1.5+ NWR/RoS integration sprint as inline research (~1-2 hours per registry). T52 UK gov agency tech + T56 document-signing eIDAS + T82 architecture-evaluation methodology cover adjacent ground.

Cascade artefacts

  • arch-state v3.24 → v3.25 (commit ec94b05)
  • ζ-Q13 cascade file moved current-questions/ → answered-questions/ (commit d560546)
  • ζ-Q13 §14 closure block + frontmatter answered (commit e9b8f79)
  • INDEX v2.15 → v2.16 (this commit)
  • Architecture-options scorecard v2.13 → v2.14 status note (this commit)
  • This memory file (this commit)
  • active-work-log + MEMORY.md (this commit)

NEXT

ζ-Q14 = alignment-axiom strength FRESH under R2 framing per Rich directive 2026-05-01: “alignment-axiom strength or t-box layering… need to be revisited due to us reversing ω.γ Hybrid multi-parent lock”. ζ-Q5 was locked under ω.γ (BFO 2020 + PROV-O dual-upper + Prudhomme); MQ-001 R2 partial-amended (Prudhomme dropped) but never fresh-asked under R2. Rich requested fresh-ask + “genuinely innovative answers”.

ζ-Q6 t-box layering was R2-reframed when locked (φ.α’ α 3-layer status quo) so does not need fresh-ask.

Graph View

Backlinks