TT Claude Memory

project_zeta_q24_locked_phi_eta_2026_05_05

Properties1
description2026-05-05T09:35 BST. SECOND v3.12 production use validated. Phase 2 architecture-options selection 20th lock. A-164 amendment arch-state v3.58→v3.59 (A-143 candidate promoted to A-164). Φ.η constrained-bold-synthesis = OPEN-pillar + R-029 12-18mo Catala first-mover window forcing function + Q-015 λ.η wave-per-pillar codification + 5-criteria composite Phase-1.5+ activation trigger + per-pillar T49 cumulative-state Phase-1 + advisory-panel charter Phase-1.5+ pre-wave + UK Muslim ≥10 firms + UK Jewish Beth Din mediation-only + UK Hindu OPEN advisory representation Day-1. 13 sub_clarifications_locked. Wsum 4.79 margin 0.29 ROBUST. SIXTEENTH refined-prompt-era lock; FIFTEENTH consecutive bold-synthesis with explicit N≥5 counter-pattern check yielding CONSTRAINED-bold-synthesis. 5 architectural axes substantially decided. NEXT Q-025 Phase 2 closure-check META-Q likely.

6 min read

Q-024 LOCKED Φ.η ★ — Faith-tradition Phase-1.5+ wave-1 activation-trigger META-Q (constrained-bold-synthesis) 2026-05-05

Lock summary

Locked option: Φ.η ★ constrained-bold-synthesis OPEN-pillar with 5-criteria composite Phase-1.5+ activation trigger. Locked 2026-05-05T09:35 BST per Rich approval “lock Φ.η. use refined-end-of-turn-directive.md for the next question”. A-164 amendment arch-state v3.58 → v3.59 §4 lastmod-prose. A-143 candidate (Spike 6 T-NEW-S6-12 PROMOTE-TO-A-N) formally promoted to A-164. SECOND v3.12 production use validated.

Components (5+ Day-1 patterns composed)

  1. OPEN-pillar selection (Φ.ζ baseline) — wave-1 pillar identity OPEN; first-evidence-wins; no pre-selection
  2. R-029 12-18mo Catala first-mover window forcing function — wave-1 SHOULD fire within 12-18mo if any pillar accumulates ≥3 of 5 triggers
  3. Q-015 λ.η wave-per-pillar codification — Q-024 specifies wave-1 trigger criteria for committed pattern
  4. 5-criteria composite Phase-1.5+ activation trigger per v3.12 #9 3-field codification:
    • T1 advisory-panel ≥10 (quarterly Phase-1 review Rich+Paul+advisory-panel-coordinator; wave-1 charter doc + Q-024 §revision)
    • T2 UK partner-firm signed (≥1 firm pilot per pillar; per-engagement Rich+acquirer-DD-team-lead-when-engaged; partnership agreement + wave-1 pilot scope)
    • T3 Catala team upstreams faith-tradition primitives (R-029 positive trigger; quarterly Catala-team Zulip + GitHub monitor Rich; arch-state amendment + wave-1 timeline acceleration)
    • T4 ≥5 academic publications 2025-2030 (quarterly literature review Rich+advisory-panel; T49 corpus refresh + wave-1 evidence lock)
    • T5 jurisdictional-tooling ≥80% complete in private-fork ready for upstream (quarterly Phase-1.5+ pre-wave review Rich+Paul; wave-1 release-readiness gate + arch-state §13 row)
    • Wave-1 fires when ≥3 of 5 triggers MET on a single pillar within 12-month rolling window (composite-AND threshold; no single trigger sufficient)
  5. Per-pillar T49-evidence cumulative-state file Phase-1 (4 files: Hindu / Muslim / Jewish / Singapore-Muslim; refreshed quarterly; matches catala-formal-verification-cumulative-state-2026-05-02 pattern)
  6. Advisory-panel charter Phase-1.5+ pre-wave per pillar selected by trigger (NOT Phase-1; Phase-FIT discipline; matches Q-022 σ̃.η + Q-023 ω̃.ι phase_5_deferred_authoring pattern)
  7. UK Muslim wave-1 candidate: ≥10 specialist firms post-S1 spike (Irwin Mitchell + Slater Heelis + Myerson + Farani Taylor + I Will Solicitors + Cribbin & Co + AM Law + RHJ Devonshire + Anthony Gold + NBC; Law Society publishes formal Sharia-Wills guidance) — partner-firm-pool maturity HIGH
  8. UK Jewish wave-1 candidate: London Beth Din institutional venue exists BUT inheritance scope LIMITED to mediation ONLY per s.10 Arbitration Act 1996 carve-out (D1 substrate-correcting finding); partner-firm landscape requires Beth Din intro pathway; partner-firm-pool maturity MEDIUM
  9. UK Hindu wave-1 candidate: GENUINE OPEN — zero specialist-Hindu-succession firms; HUF coparcenary + 2005-amendment + UK Wills-Act-1837 conflict navigation needs build-from-scratch advisory panel; Φ.β R1 +£15-25K vs Muslim/Jewish baseline; partner-firm-pool maturity LOW

Sub_clarifications_locked (13 keys)

open_pillar_selection + wave_1_5_criteria_composite_trigger + q_015_lambda_eta_wave_per_pillar_codification + r_029_12_18mo_catala_window_respect + partner_firm_precedent_leverage_uk_muslim_jewish_hindu + per_pillar_t49_cumulative_state_file_phase_1 + advisory_panel_charter_phase_1_5_pre_wave + bidirectional_i18n_per_pillar + a_115_advisory_layered_preserved + a_143_candidate_promote_to_a_n_at_lock + s1_outcome_t49_corpus_refresh_validated_with_note + d1_outcome_partner_pilot_substrate_correcting + v3_12_second_production_use_compliance.

Score-frame

  • Wsum 4.79 post-spike margin 0.29 ROBUST over Φ.ζ runner-up 4.50 (above 0.20 robust threshold)
  • 7/8 perturbations favour Φ.η ★
  • Perturbation #4 c4 ÷2 (R-029 12-18mo most-relied-on per v3.12 #3) reveals c4 drives ~50% margin → flag over-reliance-detected LIGHT JUSTIFIED (R-029 is empirical risk register entry NOT speculation)
  • Perturbation #8 — A-25 stress-test forcing wave-1 Phase-1 commitment — flips to Φ.γ; NOT the case under A-115 advisory-layered

Cost rows (R3a/R3b split per v3.12 #8)

  • R1 +£2-3K (advisory-panel charter authoring + Q-024 lock cascade)
  • R2 +0.1-0.3mo
  • R3a Y1 ramp £0.5K/yr + R3b Y2+ steady £0.1K/yr (advisory-panel quarterly review)
  • R4 Y2+ uplift £80-150K per pillar wave-1 build
  • R5 5y cumulative no-uplift £3-5K
  • R6 5y acquirer-ready £80-155K (most cost is R4 wave-1 build itself; Phase-2 lock is cheap)

Reversal cost (v3.12 reversal-cost realism guard)

Φ.η ★ → Φ.ε degrade cost ~3-5 days (advisory-panel charter rewrite + trigger criteria revision); LOW because Phase-2 lock is discipline-only with NO Phase-1 deployed infrastructure.

v3.12 SECOND production use compliance

  • HARD PRE-FLIGHT PASS (Tier-2 pgvector 8 chunks sim 0.739-0.766 + 3 web tracks + T49 + T-spike-eps-iota-S1 + T61 + T37 + R-034 + R-029)
  • step 4d OPTION COMMITMENT CLASSIFICATION applied
  • symmetric ÷2 perturbation on most-relied-on c4 (#4) flag over-reliance-detected LIGHT JUSTIFIED
  • R3a Y1 ramp + R3b Y2+ steady cost split
  • 13 sub_clarifications_locked
  • N≥5 counter-pattern check explicit (yielded CONSTRAINED-bold-synthesis OPEN-pillar)
  • Phase-N+1 trigger 3-field codification across all 5 trigger criteria (no incomplete-trigger-spec flags)

Substrate-correcting findings (per v3.11 Harvard-depth + v3.12 inline spikes)

  1. 🚨 London Beth Din inheritance scope LIMITED to mediation ONLY per s.10 Arbitration Act 1996 carve-out (D1 substrate-correcting finding) — Φ.δ Jewish-first c6 5/5→3/5 ELIMINATED; UK Jewish wave-1 partner-firm landscape weaker than initial framing implied
  2. UK Sharia-compliant Wills market mature ≥10 specialist firms (S1 — broader than initial T49 framing implied) — Φ.γ Muslim-first strengthened; Day-1 partner-firm-pool richest among 3 pillars
  3. UK Hindu private-client specialist landscape genuinely OPEN (S1 confirmed) — zero specialist-Hindu-succession firms; HUF coparcenary + 2005-amendment + UK Wills-Act-1837 conflict navigation needs build-from-scratch advisory panel
  4. R-034 cost band £80-150K/pillar/yr STANDS empirically supported by partner-firm-pool maturity differentials

2 NEW richard-tasks (Phase-1 + Phase-1.5+ pre-wave deliverables)

  • Per-pillar T49-evidence cumulative-state file Phase-1 (4 files: Hindu / Muslim / Jewish / Singapore-Muslim; quarterly refresh; matches catala-formal-verification-cumulative-state-2026-05-02 pattern)
  • Advisory-panel charter Phase-1.5+ pre-wave per pillar selected by trigger; charter scope includes recruitment + cadence + decision-rights

Pattern observations

  • SIXTEENTH refined-prompt-era ζ.2 lock outside Group 1 (Q-005 + Q-006..Q-015 + Q-019 + Q-021 + Q-022 + Q-023 + Q-024)
  • FIFTEENTH consecutive bold-synthesis substrate-architectural lock with explicit N≥5 counter-pattern check confirming OPEN-pillar substrate-derived but pillar selection aspiration-derived → CONSTRAINED bold-synthesis (composes 5+ patterns Day-1 while RESPECTING Phase-FIT step 4d + A-115 advisory-layered)
  • 15-Q lock cadence ~13.4h since 2026-05-04T20:10 BST σ.η-on-demand
  • 5 architectural axes substantially decided: Q-019 ε.ζ TIMING + Q-021 χ.η WIRE FORMATS + Q-022 σ̃.η GATE SEQUENCE + Q-023 ω̃.ι VERIFICATION TIER ESCALATION + Q-024 Φ.η FAITH-TRADITION WAVE-1 ACTIVATION
  • 2 inline lock-DEFERABLE spikes ran inline 2026-05-05T09:25 BST matching Q-022 σ̃.η inline-spike pattern; substrate-correcting finding (Beth Din inheritance mediation-only) eliminated Φ.δ Jewish-first as serious contender post-spike

Cascade artefacts

  • A-164 amendment arch-state v3.58 → v3.59 §4 lastmod-prose (A-143 candidate promoted)
  • Q-024 cascade-Q file at docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-29-multi-phase-audit/answered-questions/Q-024-zeta-faith-tradition-phase-1-5-wave-1-trigger-locked.md v1.0 NEW
  • INDEX.md asked 19→20 + answered 19→20 + placeholder stays 5 + lastmod-prose Q-024 entry + version 2.25 → 2.26
  • Memory file (this file) saved + MEMORY.md index entry
  • active-work-log Q-024 lock entry
  • 2 NEW richard-tasks (per-pillar T49 cumulative-state Phase-1 + advisory-panel charter Phase-1.5+ pre-wave)
  • Commit + push origin/main pending

NEXT Q

Q-025 = Phase 2 closure-check META-Q (likely; ω.γ shape declaring Phase-2 substantively done; 5 architectural axes substantially decided; transition to Phase-3 module-authoring; κ.θ AHP weights externalised richard-task #205 cannot be Q-025 directly) under refined-prompt v3.12.

Graph View

Backlinks