⚠️ PRE-REFINED-PROMPT-archived 2026-05-01T20:45 BST per Full Phase-2-3 Reversion — this memory file records a lock that has been DISCARDED. The Q is queued for re-ask under refined-prompt v3.0 discipline. Original lock content preserved below for forensic continuity. Do not act on this memory’s recommendations as if locked. Audit-record:
~/testatetech/docs-strategy/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-29-multi-phase-audit/audit-records/2026-05-01-full-phase-2-3-re-ask-under-refined-prompt.mdv1.0. Refined-prompt v3.0 reference:~/testatetech/docs-strategy/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-29-multi-phase-audit/refined-end-of-turn-directive.md.
ζ-Q5 Alignment-axiom strength LOCKED ψ.γ SSSOM-canonical + Prudhomme-vendored — 2026-04-30T21:15 BST
Decision
ψ.γ iv-5 SSSOM-canonical + Prudhomme-vendored locked under G+ permanent + ε + ω.γ Hybrid multi-parent. A-22 iv-3 → iv-5 evolution: per-target alignment-axiom-strength matrix moves from doc-level into code-inherit-v2/alignments/inherit.sssom.tsv v1.0 (SSSOM v1.1 schema + LinkML extensions). Prudhomme 2025 alignment file vendored to code-inherit-v2/alignments/prudhomme-prov-bfo-2025/ with Zenodo DOI + SHA256 pin.
Why: alignment-axiom-current-practice 2026-04-23 (91% confidence) confirmed A-22 predicate-strength rules (rdfs:subClassOf default, owl:equivalentClass sparingly) match 2024-2026 consensus across SSSOM + FIBO + BFO + OBO Foundry. T10 SSSOM confirmed A-33 already-locked Phase-1 audit-wide standard with mature production toolchain (sssom-java 1.5.0 + ROBOT plugin + Mondo Feb 2026 SSSOM-authoritative). ψ.γ operationalises both + adds Prudhomme-vendoring for Zenodo DOI stability mitigation.
How to apply: All Phase-3 module-authoring emits alignment axioms via SSSOM v1.1 TSV rows; ROBOT sssom:inject Phase-1 build step generates OWL artefacts; SSSOM SHACL shape generation eliminates parallel hand-authoring. A-20.1 schema downgrade applied (richard-tasks #195). Prudhomme 2025 axioms vendored locally — Zenodo DOI monthly check demoted to quarterly upstream-comparison (richard-tasks #192). 3 T12 tensions absorbed as TSV rows.
Configuration
| Element | Value |
|---|---|
| A-22 iv-3 → iv-5 | Per-target matrix → inherit.sssom.tsv v1.0 (SSSOM v1.1 + LinkML extensions) |
| A-33 SSSOM pin | sssom_version: 1.1 (not 1.0); sssom-java 1.5.0 + ROBOT plugin in CI |
| A-63 SPARINGLY gate | iri_verified_date 12-month re-verification cadence per A-20 IRI-verify scar |
| A-21 CI gates | 20 → 21 (G-SSSOM-VALIDATE new; G-PRUDHOMME-INTEGRITY at 20 from A-129) |
| A-20.1 axiom | DOWNGRADED inherit-fnd:Role owl:equivalentClass cmns-rlcmp:Role → rdfs:subClassOf (per current-practice §5 90% confidence; P3 FIBO + P4 BFO + P5 no-co-ownership) |
| Prudhomme 2025 | Vendored to code-inherit-v2/alignments/prudhomme-prov-bfo-2025/ + Zenodo DOI 10.5281/zenodo.14692262 + SHA256 pin |
| T-NEW absorbed | T-NEW-FIBO-CMNS-PIN HIGH (Commons 1.3 stable); T-NEW-LADM-SCOPE MEDIUM (Parts 1+2 IN; 4 maybe; 3+5 OUT); T-NEW-CL-CIDOC-LRMOO LOW (Phase-1.5+ deferred) |
| Standards positioning | First cross-domain legal SSSOM catalog narrative for ISO PAS 2028-2030 |
Scoring
5 options against locked 14-criterion C frame: ψ.γ SSSOM+Prudhomme-vendored 4.06 / ψ.β SSSOM-canonical 3.92 / ψ.δ INHERIT-bridge 3.78 / ψ.ε LinkML-derivation 3.55 / ψ.α status-quo 3.45. ψ.γ wins 6/8 sensitivity perturbations. Margin to ψ.β = 0.14 (BELOW 0.20 auto-deep-dive threshold — second consecutive ζ.2 below-threshold decision after ζ-Q4 0.09).
Cascade artefacts
- arch-state Tier-1 v3.14 → v3.15 + A-130 amendment + Shape X §3 angle (iv) row update + A-22/A-33/A-63/A-20.1 update
- INDEX v2.5 → v2.6
- 2026-04-18 architecture-options scorecard v2.3 → v2.4 status note
- ζ-Q5 cascade file moved current-questions/ → answered-questions/
- richard-tasks-tt #194 (SSSOM v1.1 catalog scaffolding Phase-1 Sprint S1 execution) + #195 (A-20.1 schema downgrade execution); #192 demoted monthly→quarterly
- NEW Phase-1 artefact:
code-inherit-v2/alignments/inherit.sssom.tsvv1.0 (~30-40 alignment axiom rows) - NEW Phase-1 artefact:
code-inherit-v2/alignments/prudhomme-prov-bfo-2025/(vendored + provenance attribution)
Methodological observations
- Second consecutive below-0.20-margin decision (ζ-Q4 0.09 + ζ-Q5 0.14). Multi-line scorecard format codified for below-threshold ζ.2 decisions per
feedback_below_threshold_multi_line_scorecard. - Convergent decision pattern continues (4 of 5 ζ-decisions convergent under ζ.2; only ζ-Q2 G+ permanent was Rich-divergent).
- A-20.1 SCHEMA DOWNGRADE folded into ζ-Q5 cascade rather than authored as separate amendment — pattern: when current-practice synthesis surfaces consequential schema-level recommendation aligned with the architectural option being locked, fold the schema change into the cascade with explicit registry mention. Cleaner audit trail.
- First major operational-infrastructure decision under ζ.2 — previous ζ-decisions (criteria frame / architecture options / asset taxonomy / upper ontology) were architectural-structural; ψ.γ is operational-infrastructural. Cascades into BUILD-PLAN.md per-repo execution + Phase-1 Sprint S1 scaffolding.
Honest caveats
- Vendoring discipline load-bearing: Prudhomme 2025 file at
code-inherit-v2/alignments/prudhomme-prov-bfo-2025/must carry Zenodo DOI + retrieved-date + SHA256 pin. If any slips, ψ.γ degrades to ψ.β-equivalent. - A-20.1 downgrade is consequential: schema change affects 14th canonical primitive Role + RoleInstance ODP. Phase-1 Sprint S1 execution per richard-tasks #195. Cross-module primitive references using Role need verification post-downgrade.
- 3 T12 tensions absorbed but not all closed: T-NEW-FIBO-CMNS-PIN HIGH absorbed via TSV row but Commons 1.3 → 1.4 RTF churn remains; T-NEW-LADM-SCOPE Part-4 valuation status TBD; T-NEW-CL-CIDOC-LRMOO Phase-1.5+ deferred.
- LinkML-derivation (ψ.ε) Phase-2+ optionality preserved: if LinkML 1.11+ delivers production-grade SSSOM derivation by Q3-Q4 2026, ψ.ε scores rise materially. Promotion path from ψ.γ → ψ.ε straightforward.
- Smith Ch 7 Relations targeted-deep flagged for next session — alignment-axiom predicate semantics under BFO upper would benefit from depth-read.