TT Claude Memory

project_zeta_q8_lambda_beta_phase_2_closed_2026_05_01

Properties1
descriptionClass boundaries (Role+RoleInstance ODP) locked at Λ.β multi-anchor SSSOM alignment + Donohue 2017 IRI spike executed (IAO_0000033 confirmed) + PHASE 2 CLOSED — all 8 Shape X angles answered under R2

3 min read

⚠️ PRE-REFINED-PROMPT-archived 2026-05-01T20:45 BST per Full Phase-2-3 Reversion — this memory file records a lock that has been DISCARDED. The Q is queued for re-ask under refined-prompt v3.0 discipline. Original lock content preserved below for forensic continuity. Do not act on this memory’s recommendations as if locked. Audit-record: ~/testatetech/docs-strategy/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-29-multi-phase-audit/audit-records/2026-05-01-full-phase-2-3-re-ask-under-refined-prompt.md v1.0. Refined-prompt v3.0 reference: ~/testatetech/docs-strategy/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-29-multi-phase-audit/refined-end-of-turn-directive.md.

ζ-Q8 Class boundaries LOCKED Λ.β + PHASE 2 CLOSED — 2026-05-01T04:33 BST

Decision

Λ.β Status quo + multi-anchor SSSOM alignment locked under R2 (ω.α + ψ.γ’ + ε + φ.α’ + χ.γ + G+ permanent). A-20 + A-20.1 PRESERVED + A-20.2/A-20.3/A-20.4 NEW sub-amendments + Donohue 2017 IRI spike executed Rich-requested.

Donohue 2017 IRI spike outcome

Critical finding: Donohue 2017 paper has NO separate IRI namespace. Framework reuses IAO (Information Artifact Ontology) directive information entity class.

  • IRI: http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/IAO_0000033
  • IAO release v2026-03-30 (April 10, 2026) — production-grade + OBO Foundry canonical + CC BY 4.0 + actively maintained
  • De-risks Λ.β — most uncertain anchor confirmed-stable

Configuration

  • A-20 + A-20.1 PRESERVED (RoleInstance 14th canonical + ψ.γ’ schema downgrade)
  • A-20.2 NEW: Role+RoleInstance multi-anchor SSSOM — 8 TSV rows in inherit.sssom.tsv:
    • Role peers: PROV-O Agent + BFO_0000023 + cmns-rlcmp:Role + DOLCE Role SEE-ALSO
    • RoleInstance peers: PROV-O qualifiedAttribution + BFO_0000023 (reified) + IAO_0000033 (Donohue framework) + cmns-rlcmp:Designation Phase-1.5 trigger
  • A-20.3 NEW: per-Role-+-RoleInstance INHERIT-specific SHACL shapes (Witness/Trustee/Executor/Beneficiary/Capacity Attestor)
  • A-20.4 NEW: Role+RoleInstance ODP per-module authoring guidance
  • A-21 CI gates UNCHANGED at 21 (existing G-SSSOM-VALIDATE + G-SKOHUB-SHACL-VALIDATE cover)

Phase 2 closure

ζ-Q8 closes Phase 2 — all 8 Shape X angles answered under R2:

  • (i) Top-level Asset class — ζ-Q3 ε with 9 i-ζ classes (A-128)
  • (ii) Class boundaries — ζ-Q8 Λ.β multi-anchor SSSOM (A-134 NEW)
  • (iii) Upper ontology — ζ-Q4 ω.γ → R2 reverted ω.α (A-131)
  • (iv) Alignment-axiom strength — ζ-Q5 ψ.γ → R2 partial-amend ψ.γ’ (A-131)
  • (v) T-box layering — ζ-Q6 R2-reframed φ.α’ (A-132)
  • (vi) Faceted classification — ζ-Q7 χ.γ vi-6+ Hybrid (A-133 + 4 sub-amendments)
  • (vii) Modularity — vii-3 21-gate CI extended
  • (viii) OWL profile per layer — viii-3 multi-profile via OUTPUT-level ROBOT (operationalised by φ.α’)

Methodological observations

  • In-session spike execution validates spike-then-decide pattern: Rich-requested Donohue 2017 IRI spike executed in ~5 min via WebSearch + WebFetch; outcome integrated directly into Λ.β cascade. Codify as feedback_inline_spike_execution_for_load_bearing_decisions discipline.
  • Above-threshold cluster confirmed: 3 consecutive above-threshold decisions (MQ-001 R2 0.36 + ζ-Q7 0.40 + ζ-Q8 0.24) post-reversal. Architecture under R2 is genuinely coherent.
  • Phase 2 closure marker: this is the FIRST ζ.2 phase to close formally. Per design-spec §6.3 mitigation 2, build-readiness dry-run (MQ-002) is the next discipline trigger.
  • Convergent decision pattern continues: 8 of 9 ζ.2-related decisions convergent (only ζ-Q2 G+ permanent was Rich-divergent).

Cascade artefacts

  • arch-state Tier-1 v3.18 → v3.19 + A-134 amendment + 3 sub-amendments (A-20.2/A-20.3/A-20.4) + Shape X §3 angle (ii) row update
  • INDEX v2.9 → v2.10 (Phase 2 closure marker)
  • 2026-04-18 architecture-options scorecard v2.7 → v2.8 status note (Phase 2 closure)
  • ζ-Q8 cascade file moved current-questions/ → answered-questions/
  • richard-tasks-tt v1.13 → v1.14 with #200 simplified + #201 + #202

Honest caveats

  • Donohue framework reuse via IAO IRI is now SPIKE-CONFIRMED stable — significantly de-risks Phase-1 SSSOM TSV authoring.
  • Other anchor IRIs (PROV-O / BFO 2020 / cmns-rlcmp:Role / DOLCE Role) defer to Phase-1 Sprint S1 spike per #197 — known-stable canonical sources.
  • Commons 1.3 Designation peer still Phase-1.5 trigger per A-23.1; not blocking Phase-1 SSSOM TSV.
  • Phase-2+ optionality: Λ.γ RoleAssertion rename remains as Phase-2+ revisit option if Phase-3 module-authoring surfaces Role design pain-points (richard-tasks-eligible).

Graph View

Backlinks